John asked me to post this, so I will:

Well, to say the least, I don’t agree with much.  🙂  I’m just too much of a pragmatist.  I would say my biggest problem with the posting is that the downsides are never presented in any of the posts.  It’s as if we could have free migration without consequences.  I know Matt and Kiel are both liberals, and yet they pretend as though the state functions by itself.  It’s as if this whole discussion is missing reality.  So it’s very difficult for me, or anyone else, to listen to this talk of “justice” and “rightness” from all of these individuals who aren’t at the same time asking for an objectivist, minimalist state.  You can’t have both.

I know you understand what I’m talking about, but I’m not sure anyone else on the boards does.  I know, I know, I sound like I’m trying to break down your wall. 🙂


website metrics