Today, I gave this speech to the Brownsville City Council Meeting during the public comment portion. The Brownsville Herald ran an article on Sunday that said that the Mayor was betrayed by the City Council who went behind closed doors to allow the Army Corps of Engineers onto city land to survey for the wall. It is in response to that that I wrote this speech-on the back, and in the margins of the agenda.
Yesterday, Princeton University recognized five of my 8th grade students for essays they wrote on the topic “What would Martin Luther King say and do about immigration?” Princeton opened this year’s essay contest to my students because they used my blog, nonviolent migration, as a resource for their contest. These five students, Melissa Guerra, Yessenia Martinez, Abigail Cabrera, Vanessa Trevino, and Blanca Gonzalez were the only five students who had the faith to submit an essay and all were recognized by Princeton.
I asked the rest of my 121 students to speak honestly about why they had decided not to write for the contest. The overwhelming number of students responded that it wasn’t worth trying because they felt that because Princeton is in the North, they would prejudge their work since they live on the border. This experience reminded me once again just how excluded these children feel. Even though this wall will be South of most of my students, my students are smart enough to know that the same motive behind this wall is also shouting at them, saying, “You are not us; keep out!”
These students, who started with such enthusiasm when the contest was announced, lost hope and they let their fears overcome their faith. This broke my heart because I love my students, but your capitulation is something other than heartbreaking because you are no longer 8th graders. We expect you to hold out hope. We expect you to keep the faith. We expect you to work for us, and let us fight this fight.
At this time, we want to express our love… and forgiveness… to all the members of the commission. However, as a result of your action, we must now find a legal way to undo what you’ve done so that my 8th graders don’t come to learn that you prejudged them too.